Please use this page to discuss pages that have been labeled for deletion.
Category:Game reports[]
Being temporarily empty is no reason to delete a useful category. -- Robin Patterson (Talk) 23:21, March 25, 2016 (UTC)
- Apparently I missed the useful point in addition to the good category:Gameplay for Why I am better than Freeciv's AI. Maybe you want something remotely in the direction of category:Fan art to collect unclear contributions, but IMO this should not end up in the top-level category:Browse. If you find a better place for category:Game reports I'm quite willing to undo the damage (= re-insert the AI page and drop the deletion request.) Dunnoob (talk) 23:06, March 30, 2016 (UTC)
- I can't see a better parent category for it except perhaps Category:Documentation. Category:Browse on this wiki does not follow the old Wikia standard of having just Content and Files and Organization. It contains fairly low level categories such as Copyright and Disambiguation pages. I think Game reports is OK among those, but Documentation would be OK. -- Robin Patterson (Talk) 22:14, May 23, 2016 (UTC)
category:Comparisons should not be deleted[]
Category:Comparisons is not "covered" by category:Tutorials. It's a category about analytical information, which may be of interest to some players and developers, but is not the same as "tutorial", which is about teaching people how to do something. "Comparisons" should be retained, and should have its former contents returned to it, even if they may also be suitable for "Tutorials". -- Robin Patterson (Talk) 23:51, June 9, 2016 (UTC)
- This category consisted of three pages: Civ2/Andrew, a 2003 mail rescued from a mail archive before Wikia forums existed, Comparison of Freeciv's civ2 modpack and Civilization II, a page interesting for folks knowing Civ II if they try the civ2 ruleset, and How to update a ruleset from 2.5 to 2.6, one of the 8+5+2 "how to update" pages.
- That was an inconsistent collection of unrelated topics, unlike Category:Tutorials (for the comparison), Category:Editing rulesets (for the howto), and no category for the subpage with an email sent a decade before civ2civ3. –Dunnoob 💩 01:28, June 10, 2016 (UTC)